GI SPECIAL
4G11:
THIS IS HOW BUSH BRINGS THE TROOPS HOME:
BRING THEM ALL HOME NOW, ALIVE
April 28, 2005 National Security Archive
Electronic Briefing Book No. 152
“Opposing This War IS Defending This
Country”
“All I Wanted To See Was The Town Of Baiji
Leveled”
“I Now Understand, Very Well, How War Crimes
Happen”
From: Andrew Sapp [Excerpts]
To: GI Special
Sent: July 08, 2006
I'd like to thank you for GI Special. I found it last year while I was still serving
in Iraq, and it helped keep me sane.
I shared stories with a number of my buddies,
and they went a long way in helping them try to make some sense out the
insanity that is Iraq.
I joined IVAW while I was still
there, and have been active ever since.
Opposing this war IS defending
this country.
I'm sending an article by a
reporter who covered a talk I gave a couple of days ago, in case you're
interested.
Thanks again, and keep up the
fight!
"In the beginning of
change...the patriot is a scarce man, who is brave, hated, and scorned. When his cause succeeds, the timid join him;
for then it costs nothing to be a patriot." ~Mark Twain
REPLY:
It's an honor to have been of service to you,
and your buddies. It's you who have
earned the thanks, for your service, and for speaking out, and telling people
the truth.
Sitting in a chair putting together a
newsletter is nothing compared to serving in Iraq, and deciding to take action
against a wrong done to those who have served, both the living and the dead.
T
*********************************************
“This Is What We Have Done”
“We Will Carry This Burden Until We Are
Old”
July 07, 2006 Eagle-Tribune, North Andover,
MA
ANDOVER:
Andrew Sapp made up his mind
last year while he was outside the Iraqi town of Baiji.
A staff sergeant with the
Massachusetts Army National Guard, he had long opposed the war in Iraq, but not
publicly.
Standing in a guard tower on
Aug. 9, 2005, Sapp saw a flash in the sky.
"A moment later the ground
shook. It really shook," Sapp, who
lives in Billerica, told a group of about 75 summer session students at
Phillips Academy last night.
Two roadside bombs had exploded
nearby, Sapp said. The second, meant for
a tank, hit an American Humvee. The
gunner on the vehicle was thrown 50 feet but survived. Four others, members of the Pennsylvania
National Guard, died.
"They had to pick pieces
of them out of trees," Sapp told the high school-age students.
The stress of the memory was
enough to drive feelings of intense anger through his mind and send Sapp into
counseling.
"All I wanted to see was
the town of Baiji leveled," he told the group. "I now understand,
very well, how war crimes happen."
Sapp's story hushed the
students as he told them about an organization he has joined, Iraq Veterans
Against the War which was started in Boston.
The speech and ensuing discussion was part of
the first of a weekly series at Phillips Academy held in honor of the activism
of W.E.B. DuBois. Also speaking were
Charley Richardson and Nancy Lessin of Jamaica Plain, a married couple who
helped to found Military Families Speak Out in 2002.
Military Families Speak Out, which Lessin
said includes more than 3,000 families, is calling for a complete, immediate
withdrawal of troops from Iraq. Iraq Veterans Against the War has the same
goal.
Marine Joe Richardson, son of Richardson and
Lessin, was in Iraq for several months leading up to and including the March
2003 invasion of the country.
The students were attentive to the speeches,
especially when Sapp, an English teacher at Concord High School, spoke.
After the presentations, students questioned
the speakers on whether their organizations were making progress and if they
would support the Iraq invasion if there had been a quick withdrawal.
When asked by the speakers who has relatives
or friends in Iraq, only two hands in the crowd were raised. One belonged to
Jon Christman, 17, a summer session student from Atlanta. Christman asked the
group to acknowledge some positive aspects of the war.
"In the very least, we've thrown out a
dictator who gassed his own people," Christman said. After the event, he said friends of his
family are in Iraq. He also said he was
uncertain if some of the statistics quoted by the speakers were accurate.
The presentation, though,
involved more than statistics.
Sapp said there was a very real
consequence to both the roadside bomb that killed four American soldiers and the
war as a whole. He described his
struggles with post-traumatic stress disorder.
"I'm sleeping better
now," he said, adding that in his mind "I don't hear as many
explosions as I used to."
"You will live with this
too," he told the students. "This is what we have done. We will carry this burden until we are
old."
www.ivaw.net
Do you have a friend or relative in the
service? Forward this E-MAIL along, or
send us the address if you wish and we’ll send it regularly. Whether in Iraq or stuck on a base in the
USA, this is extra important for your service friend, too often cut off from
access to encouraging news of growing resistance to the war, at home and inside
the armed services. Send requests to address up
top.
IRAQ WAR REPORTS
Ramadi IED Destroys Cougar:
Three Soldiers Dead
July 8, 2006 Julian E. Barnes and Borzou
Daragahi, LATimes Staff Writers
Three U.S. soldiers scouring
the treacherous roads of western Iraq for remote-controlled explosive devices
were killed by a massive roadside bomb that destroyed their heavily protected
vehicle, U.S. military officials said.
The three soldiers were part of the U.S. Army
1st Armored Division's Task Force Dagger, which sweeps major roads in Ramadi
for bombs under the command of the U.S. Marines.
They were riding in a heavily
armored Cougar, a vehicle designed to withstand unexpected roadside bombs and
used in mine sweeping operations.
The Pentagon last year ordered 122 of the
mine-sweeping Cougars worth a total of $87 million from Force Protection, Inc.,
the Ladson, S.C. firm that makes the vehicle and its spare parts.
The Cougars "feature armor-plated
V-shaped bottoms designed to deflect the upward explosive power of roadside
bombs," said the company's website.
But since the 1st Armored Division units
moved into the area, some Marines say they believe insurgents have been placing
larger roadside bombs to take out the Germany-based unit's fleet of armored
tanks and Bradley fighting vehicles.
Detroit Lakes Area Soldier Killed
07/09/06 AP
A Detroit Lakes area soldier was killed in
Iraq when a roadside bomb went off near the Humvee he was driving, relatives
said Sunday.
Army Spec. Troy Carlin Linden, 22, of
Rochert, was killed in Anbar province on Saturday, his siblings said. He had been home on leave just six months
earlier, when his family threw him a surprise welcome home party.
The family's farm home east of Detroit Lakes
was decorated with flags and ribbons on Sunday as relatives and friends
gathered together. "When we see a
flag, we think of Troy," said his brother, Ryan Linden.
Troy Linden was a 2002 graduate of Detroit
Lakes High School. He enlisted in the Army in Billings, Mont., where he had
moved after graduating, but his siblings described him as a Minnesotan through
and through. They said he was a humble all-American who was proud to serve his
country.
"I noticed a real change in my brother
from the time he went to basic training and then overseas," Ryan Linden
said. "For the first time I didn't see him as my little brother, I saw him
as a man."
He said his brother, in his phone calls from
Iraq, would try to ease their mother's mind by telling her he drove the last
truck in the convoy, even when he didn't.
"It was hard to hear his voice over
there because we could tell how sad he was because he wanted to be home, but we
reassured him that we loved him and how proud we were of him," his brother
said.
His sister, Sarah Nelson, also expressed
pride. "I was proud of him the day
he joined the service, and I was proud of him every step he took," she
said.
Troy Linden's dog, Rusty, has been staying
with the relatives.
"He was looking forward to having a dog
and coming home and teaching him how to swim, play, taking him Jeeping with him
and stuff," his sister said.
Funeral arrangements were pending, but his
family said he will be buried in Detroit Lakes, tentatively late next week.
"He'll never be gone, he'll always be a
part of us. He'll be with us forever," Nelson said.
Forty-one people with Minnesota
ties have died in connection with the war in Iraq and Afghanistan.
REALLY
BAD IDEA:
NO MISSION;
HOPELESS WAR:
BRING THEM ALL HOME
NOW
U.S. Marine Cpl. Brad Bruce, center, of
LaPorte, Ind., Cpl. Tyler Warndorf, right, of Hebron, Ky., and a translator,
study a map before a patrol, in Ramadi June 25, 2006. (AP Photo/Jacob
Silberberg)
Three U.S. Troops Wounded In Qadamiya
10 July 2006 By Patrick Cockburn, The
Independent UK
Iraqi troops, backed by US forces, attacked
the Shia stronghold of Qadamiya, killing nine people, wounding 30 and arresting
seven.
Three Americans and one Iraqi government
soldier were wounded.
Bomb Strikes Convoy
In Ramadi;
Four Wounded
July 10, 2006 Associated Press
The explosion occurred near the convoy as it
was headed to the government center in the insurgent-ridden city, 70 miles west
of Baghdad. Four coalition forces were
wounded, the military said in a statement.
AFGHANISTAN WAR REPORTS
Canadian Killed, Two More Wounded In Zharew
7.10.06 Boston Globe
In Kandahar province, fighting killed at
least 15 militants and one Canadian. Two
other Canadian soldiers were wounded in the province's Zharew district, the
scene of some of the fiercest fighting in an anti-Taliban offensive being waged
across the south.
Most of the fighting occurred in fields and
orchards where small bands of Taliban fighters took cover.
Three Foreign Occupation Troops Wounded In
Uruzgan:
Nationality Not Announced
July 10, 2006 AEST
US and Afghan government forces attacked an
insurgent stronghold in the southern province of Uruzgan,
One member of the Afghan security forces was
killed and three members of the US-led coalition force were wounded in the
attack on the compound, 10 kilometres north of the provincial capital, Tirin
Kot, it said.
Apaches And Land Rovers Versus A Guy With A
Detonator;
“They Fight Us Like They Fought The
Russians:
Hit And Run”
Whether
military action combined with "hearts and minds" will succeed remains
an open question. "The Taliban can afford to wait," said one western
security official in southern Afghanistan. "They don't need a £38m
aircraft to kill their enemies - just a few old weapons," he said.
[Thanks to JM, who sent this in.]
July 10, 2006 Declan Walsh in Camp Bastion,
The Guardian, [Excerpts]
The British Apache attack helicopters have
blunted numerous Taliban offensives and become a key battlefield weapon,
according to commanders who are quickly forgetting earlier controversies over
the £38m-per-plane cost and training delays.
And although the insurgents are little match
for the Apaches - just one bullet has hit an Apache, passing harmlessly through
the helicopter's rump - they find ways to dodge the helicopters.
"They fight us like they
fought the Russians: hit and run," said J.
That association could signal another looming
problem.
The use of extreme force has
already dented efforts to win hearts and minds among Afghan villagers, many of
whom are convinced the British have come to avenge the last colonial defeat in
1880.
Officers admit they are worried that the
screaming warplanes and bloody battles could rouse memories of the Soviet
occupation in the 1980s, which prompted thousands of southern villagers to take
up arms.
"There's a lot of
suspicion," said Maj Williams. "There's a danger people will see us
as the new Soviets. We're always looking for a softer image."
Whether military action
combined with "hearts and minds" will succeed remains an open
question. "The Taliban can afford to wait," said one western security
official in southern Afghanistan. "They don't need a £38m aircraft to kill
their enemies - just a few old weapons," he said.
"And it doesn't matter how
many Apaches or armoured Land Rovers you have. That still won't stop a guy with
a fuse and a detonator planting a bomb on the side of the road."
“Former Colonel Of 1st Battalion Accused The
Government Of Lacking A Strategy For Afghanistan”
[Thanks to JM, who sent this in.]
July 10, 2006 Richard Norton-Taylor and
Jeevan Vasagar, The Guardian [Excerpt]
Infantry from the Royal Irish Regiment will
go to Afghanistan to reinforce severely stretched British forces battling
Taliban militants, the defence secretary Des Browne is expected to announce
today.
Tim Collins, former colonel of
1st Battalion, Royal Irish Regiment, yesterday accused the government of
lacking a strategy for Afghanistan.
He told BBC TV's Sunday
AM: "We have a British government
that has no idea of what it wants to do.
It's invited the Army to go to Iraq, to Afghanistan, and do stuff. It would be a bit like giving your keys to
builders and say go and do some stuff in my house."
TROOP NEWS
HELP!
THE FORT LEE PEACE GROUP IS BEING PRESSURED BY
LOCAL POLICE
To: Veterans For Peace [VetPax]
Sent: July 09, 2006
Subject: HELP! THE FORT LEE PEACE GROUP IS
BEING PRESSURED BY LOCAL POLICE/ A cry for help!
VFP, IVAW & VVAW members
If you can make it to this
vigil to show support, I'm sure they would appreciate having veterans back them
up.
Please pass this message on.
Ken Dalton
Veterans For Peace Chapter 21
From: Stephen Palmino
Sent: Sun, 9 Jul 2006
Subject: FW: HELP! THE FORT LEE PEACE GROUP
IS BEING PRESSURED BY
LOCAL POLICE/ A cry for help!
Friends,
Please pass this word far and
wide. We can not ignore the request for support. Try your best to be there next
Thursday, please, even if it is just one day.
I will be there. If one of us is pressured, we are all
pressured.
Steve
*********************************************************
7/7/2006 Arya Jenkins
Hi Everyone:
On at least two occasions, on
the 4th when a few of us paraded quietly and peacefully through a multitude of
watchers who came to see fireworks in Fort Lee, and today, when the Fort Lee
Peace Group had its standard vigil from 4:30 pm to 5:30 pm on the corner of
Lemoine Avenue and Bruce Reynolds Blvd in Fort Lee, we had unpleasant and
challenging interactions with police.
We need support from other
vigilers because it appears as if we are being pressured to "go
away."
Please join us and vigil with
us for peace and for the right to be here.
On the first occasion, the 4th,
I was pulled aside by two plainclothed detectives while stepping peacefully
through a crowd carrying two signs for peace.
Officers Young and Tilton asked me for my age, name and ID.
I didn't have ID and they
proceeded to ask me, "Then, how do we know you are who you say you are?
You're not allowed to do what you're doing."
I told them I had informed Fort Lee police
the previous day of our intentions to be present and vigil in a peaceful and
unintrusive way during the fireworks. I
told them we had received an okay and were told that we just can't interfere
with pedestrian traffic.
Furthermore, as I mentioned to the officers,
a supervising officer at the end of the street on the occasion of the 4th, had
told us it was okay to be standing at our corner with signs and to walk through
the town, as long as we "don't interfere with pedestrian traffic."
Finally, I had to mention to the officers
that I was with the media and name a couple of friends that they also know, to
cool them down a little.
They definitely looked like
they would have arrested me if I'd scratched my nose.
Finally, after a few minutes of repeating
myself, I ended up by asking their names, shaking their hands and going on my
merry way.
As I was leaving they warned me,
"Remember if you interfere with traffic, you'll get arrested."
A side note --- On the fourth a policeman
gruffly called out to me to explain what the PAZ meant on one of my signs. I
had to explain that it means PEACE in Spanish. Perhaps words with a Z are too
similar to anti-American words and symbols????
Yesterday, Thursday, I was not at the vigil
as I had a religious holiday commitment, but I was informed by two members of
the Fort Lee Peace Group that a police car came by and two officers claimed
that passersby were complaining about vigilers shouting back.